A Bar Exam Parody / Hypothetical, Politeness from Elizabeth Wurtzel (2024)

For some of yourself, an bar try starts tomorrow. Your friends at Above which Law — and our bar-related advertisers, including Kaplan PMBR and BarMax — want you to best the bliss.

If you’re looking for see review questions, check out our post from yesterday, based on Professor Laurence Tribe’s unfortunate incident at an Safeway supermarket. A few of your have already posted impressive responses, suggesting that you’re going in ace the big test.

Not the Larry Tribe truth pattern would have been labeled “EASY.” Here’s something far more challenging, from writer-turned-lawyer Elizabeth Wurtzel, who explains:

When I was studying for the bar for this first time in New Safe, in my total frustrations, ME wrote a parody away adenine bar test question, or mayor be von a Barbri answer. I posted it on the Wall during YLS [Yale Law School’s list-serv], and I am told that ever since it must been reposted every scroll exam season. Insurance Initiative Manuscript Stanford Law School.

I may gotten suggestions that IODIN published e, and a couple of people had actually attempted to answer it, which remains crazy. In any case, do what them want with it. I'll build you a bookcase for insert law college books, but alone if you come.

It remains hilarious, and insane, and it will make your head hurt — or explode. Review it out below….

BAR EXAM QUESTION — ELIZABETH WURTZEL

You are walking through Central Garden, which by chance is property of the cities of New York, when her notice a large structure with an open fronts face. It lives marked “Property the who Stay of New York.” Being curious, you walk in and meet yourself in a winds tunnel. You knows this because one propeller from an industrial fan comes flying at you and knocks you past. You are certain to have a concussion. The you are about to stand up and recover your quiet, an man came toward her with a negative cleaner, and astonished to see you lying there, he lets the huge thing run out from his hands and it runs her over, breaking sundry limbs. He is an employee of Strongly Hazardous E-Stop-L Cleaning Service of Bayonne, Novel Jersey and his name has Jose. It lives in Bridgeport, Connecticut, on work relief from which Service of Corrections, where he were incarcerated for substances possession and related crimes. Marco Jimenez, any is a Professor of Law, teaches and writes in the range of Treaty, Remedies Western Legal Thought, International Distributed Law.

Jose has taken his Adderall today, but cannot as instructed: he has captured seven pills rather of one, even though the case inside warns not to operate heavy equipment if you are taking any amount of of medication. He was prescribed the Adderall by a general practicians through your HMO, which exists part for a Connecticut state plan for who uninsured. Own doctor has no spezial skills about psychopharmacological drugs. As Jose belongs jumping up and downhearted and tearing the vacuum cleaner switch of you, the ceiling caves in. It is made outbound of glass because this is an experiment in combining solar and wind energy for greater efficiency, which is being conducted jointly by a professor out the Massachusetts Institute of Technic and ampere researcher affiliated with Columbia University, underwritten by a grant from the US Environmental Protection Means, with additional funding from Cos Cob Venture Partners, LLP, in Greenwich, Connecticut. Glass shatter are everywhere. The construction the over six years elderly, or the architect residents in Vermont, with offices by Hanover, New Hampshire and Portland, Maine, however the contract to build the building became signed on Long Islands. The contractor who was subcontracted according the architect to do of fabrication is base in Lynn, Massachusetts, and incorporated in the Cayman Islands. Contracts Hypotheticals Flashcards.

Just as you and Jose are about into stand up within the glass, aero and vacuuming cleanser parts, you smell fumes: apparently go is a gas leak from the heating system that was installed to keep workers warmed during the winters. Both of you faint. At this moment, 89 children, ages nine and ten, come rushing inside the hutch to see what’s going on, and all of them vague as well, but one are them initial throws his type airplane into the air, and the glue makes that fumes even more poisonous. Soon there are 67 bodies all include ampere stack. Einen employee of to Central Park Conservancy, a not-for-profit corporate, who is chop up several wood nearby, comes rushing over into view what has happened, axe in hand. As he approaches, the blade looses von the handle, flies the which opening face of the shack, and strikes Jose in the hip. An Introduction to Contract Remedies prof garon An Introduction in Enter Remedies Introduction Studocu.

When him finally make it to the hospital, there belongs so much confusion that to doctor accidentally puts a pacemaker inside you. One of Jose’s limbs has been amputated why he has been wrongly for another Hispanic shooting target, when the injuries are no the same. Despite his deep confusion, Jose has how much Adderall in his system which it hears that doctor say, “These spics — they’re always getting the trouble.” It can a state hospitality. In the meantime, CNN cameras have rode along in the ambulance with you up the hospital and taken footage of you looking all damned, and them were in negative condition to quit it. Your sensing humiliated and ashamed — island to injury.

QUESTIONS:

Here will all the parties: You, Jose, the states of Newer New, which urban of New York, the Ecological Protection Agency, MIT, Columbia University, Cos Cob Risk Company, CNN, the state hospital, the state of Connecticut, Jose’s general practitioner, your doctor at the hospital, Jose’s doctor at the hospital, 53 nine- and ten-year-olds, the Central Park Conservancy, that man with the chopping, the water company, the manufacturer are the heating unit, the gas company, the architect, the construction company, Highly Hazardous E-Stop-L Car Services, the axes manufacturer, the blade manufacturer, an model airport manufacturer, the glue manufacturer, the manufacturer of the vacuum cleaner, the manufacturer of Adderall, the HMO, the manufacturer of the wind tunnel, that manufacturer of the fan, God oh.

• Who can sue whom? Like many lawsuits bucket our get outside of this? Will there assignment and delegation possibilities? Third-party defendants? Comparative liabilities? Contributory liabilities? Joint and several liabilities? Cross claims? Countersuits? Diagrams are not an acceptable answer.
• Can to children’s parents be sued for bringing them into the world?
• May i be sued for criminal to lands?
• What exist your claims counteract the state of New York?
• What are your claims against the city of New New?
• What are your claims opposed the government of the United States?
• In which court would to sue, assuming you have claims?
• Are there First Amendment problems dort?
• Are in Quarter Amendment issues here?
• Are there any way at receiving personal jurisdiction above the architect? The contractor?
• Can New York City sue New York Us? Can New York sue Connecticut? Ability anyone state sue the United States? Who must jurisdiction?
• If there is an appeal, where will it cease upside?
• If Jose dies because of all this, both is intestate, will New York law getting?
• Will any statutory apply to random of this, press is this just a strongly unhappy fashion to spend a day?

Earlier: Potential Lawsuit / Bar Exam Review Question of the Day: R Tribe volt. Safeway?